SHAH ALAM: Back in early October, Malaysian Defence wrote that the Defence Ministry has issued a tender for the supply, delivery, installation, testing and commissioning of a fire control radar (FCR) KD Perak pennant number 173, the third ship of the Kedah class.
According to the tender publication, the RMN estimates that the cost of the FCR and services (installation, testing and commissioning) at RM15 million.
The tender was to close on November 11 but it was extended to November 19. However, five days after the closing, Eperolehan website has yet to specify the number of bidders and their bid prices. I hope it is just a glitch and Eperolehan will fix it soon.
I suspect however that the bidders were not shortlisted as their bid prices were much higher than the RM15 million estimated by the RMN for the tender. I stand to be corrected of course.
Anyhow, five bidders has been shortlisted for the tender to supply, deliver, install, integrating and commissioning of a fire control system for corvette KD Laksamana Muhammad Amin – pennant number 136.
The lowest bid (rounded up for brevity) is RM12.6 million and the highest one is RM15.3 million. The highest bid is higher than the RM14 million estimate by RMN. The other bids are RM12.9 million; RM13.7 million and RM14.1 million (which is also higher than the estimate cost).
Muhammad Amin is undergoing a refit at the Grade One Marine Shipyard in Lumut. She is undergoing the refit as part of the RMN’s Obsolescence Programme where her machineries and engines are replaced with new ones. She is also getting a new hull during the refit work, which Malaysian Defence called the OP Plus.
The FCS will be installed at the shipyard as the ship remained there.
— Malaysian Defence
If you like this post, buy me an espresso. Paypal Payment
View Comments (21)
I believe for KD Laksamana Muhammad Amin it would be just EO-based FCS, just like for FACs and rear gun control for Kedah-class ships
https://www.malaysiandefence.com/kd-terengganu-sailing-the-waves-again/#comment-810442
Just thinking out loud, can't the original TMX/EO on the kedah class ships be upgraded to the latest TMX/EO Mk2 of the Gowinds? Also as most of the hardware has been bought, can't the TMX/EO Mk2 that is bought for KD Mat Kilau (the 6th cancelled gowind) be transferred over to KD Perak and its sisterships instead?
What we bought for Gowinds (ordered in 2013)
12x TMX/EO Mk2 FCR
6x TMEO Mk2 EO-FCS
Any latest news on this?
https://www.malaysiandefence.com/talks-on-upgrading-the-kedah-class/
Actually the expensive items in refit is to maintain all the complex electronic fighting systems on board a naval ship. The CMS to be up to date, change the FCR if old, Radar systems, ESM systems, etc.
All this complex systems is actually not needed for a purely OPV ship (DAMEN 1800 OPV for example). The Kedah class still have all these complex systems because it is designed to be able to be a corvette in 24-48 hours when 2 missile systems is plugged in, the Exocet and RAM. TLDM so far has never tried to plug in the exocet to the Kedah-class ships, even if theoretically it is already integrated from day 1.
Moving forward, removing all these expensive items that needs to be maintained from the Kedah-class ships will simplify maintenance and reduce sustainment costs. But it will not be able to be converted into a corvette at a short notice like it can right now. But why retain and maintain such systems when we are not going to uparm the Kedahs anyway?
There are still talk about the Combat Capability Enhancement programme, whether or not its going forward is another issue.
Marhalim, is there any news about LMS B2?
Its inching forward, I am told. It maybe a derivative of the Ada class though.
... - “Actually the expensive items”
Nothing is cheap” in a refit. Not changing the electricals; not servicing the shaft; not performing preventive maintenance on the hull; etc. Which is why even refits on ships which don’t have the “ expensive items” or “complex electronic fighting systems” you referred to can run into the millions ...
... - “in 24-48 hours when 2 missile systems is plugged in,”
24 hours.
... - “ But why retain and maintain such systems when
Kel - “But it will not be able to be converted into a corvette at a short notice”
You can convert it and call it a “frigate” if you’d like.
..: - “ But why retain and maintain such systems when we are not going to uparm the Kedahs anyway?”
So? A director is still needed for the gun; a CMS to fuse everything together; a radar to detect things; a helo landing system to make it easier for the helo; a platform management; system; etc.
changing the electricals; servicing the shaft; performing preventive maintenance on the hull; etc. is the cheap part.
The expensive part is to get all the combat electronics (CMS/FCR/Radar etc) up to date.
A reason a basic OPV (like the ex USCG boats) can be refitted almost indefinitely without breaking the bank.
"So? A director is still needed for the gun; a CMS to fuse everything together; a radar to detect things; a helo landing system to make it easier for the helo; a platform management; system; etc."
It does not need to be. The DAMEN 1800 OPV does not have most of those. Commercial civilian radar/ipms system are good enough for normal patrol mission.
@hulubalang
"when we are not going to uparm the Kedahs anyway?"
That is a wrong thinking as these are TLDM ships and they must have a war time function. Removing all those sensors & systems would cripple these ships and them unable to fire missiles & whatnot.
"It maybe a derivative of the Ada class though."
Orz.. more customisation, leading more potential issues that had doomed the LCS. Why we never learn our lesson & buy off the shelf designs, and if we cannot afford for a standard Ada then stop dreaming and get a lower end ship? Sigh...
It will be a derivative as Turkey will not sell THEIR version of the ADA class. It will be similar to the Pakistani and Ukrainian versions. It will be an export version but build by a Turkish yard.
... - “The expensive part is to get all the combat electronics (CMS/FCR/Radar etc) up to date”
Almost nothing associated with a refit is “cheap”.
Which is why even refits on ships which don’t have the “ expensive items” or “complex electronic fighting systems” you referred to can run into the millions .
The bulk of our refits don’t involve getting “all the combat electronics (CMS/FCR/Radar etc) up to date” [your quote]. Difference between a refit and an upgrade :..
.... - “It does not need to be”
Many things do not have to be on paper but I wasn’t talking about things on paper ...
The ADA class costs USD250 million each. Our budget is only USD178 million per ship. That is a delta of USD71 million.
I am of the opinion that we don't need a corvette for our maritime security needs.
thats why some of the equipment will be fitted for and not equipped with...as with the specifications...
"if we cannot afford for a standard Ada then stop dreaming and get a lower end ship? Sigh…".
If we get a 'standard' ada then the LMS would have a different E&O,CMS & effectors to that of LCS thus increasing training & sustainment cost while reducing operational effectiveness.
In general the LMS2 seems going the same way as the LCS. The politicians want to buy a ship that doesn't really fit RMN operational needs & to make the ship fit RMN needs would require substantial amount of bag of money's.
From the latest reply from MENHAN in parliament, it is very clear why TLDM wants a corvette for LMS Batch 2. Because TLDM needs ships now to offset the delays of LCS Gowind. They even looked at ships that is already built to get one ASAP but none (what the menhan says) is available. In the end if need to build from scratch, those LMS Batch 2 will not arrive before the 1st LCS Gowind is completed.
That is what TLDM WANT, but is it what malaysian maritime security needs right now?
Until our politicians really include APMM (and not just TLDM) in their maritime security plans, we will have big issues to secure our waters. Our main challenge right now is the blatant encroachment by Chinese Coast Guard in Malaysian maritime zones. We cannot tend to this issue just by using TLDM and buying TLDM ships. Solving this issue using resources given to APMM will be much better option in the overall scheme of things.