SHAH ALAM: Defence white paper. Since the Defence Ministry announced that it was formulating a White Paper, last year, the minister, deputy and officials have try to explain the reasons for it.
The ministry has even come up with a graphic to explain itself.
Despite this, I believed, the ministry has yet to come up with a proper explaination on the DWP, especially to the masses. Its not easy, actually, I must admit. However, the ministry’s deputy secretary-general (administration) Karminder Singh Dhillon has managed to do just that in a column in the New Straits Times newspaper on April. 7.
Among the things he wrote:
What constitutes a DWP and why does Malaysia need one?
At the most basic level, the DWP lays out a comprehensive long-term plan for the nation’s defence.
It puts into the public sphere, the government’s commitment to the safety of the people and to the defence of the nation’s territory and interests.
At the deeper level, DWP outlines the nation’s defence strategy, capability plans and funding requirements.
It sketches out elements of the government’s defence investment, including new weapons, platforms, systems, and the enabling equipment, facilities, workforce, information and communications technology, science and technology as well as plans for its defence industry.
More importantly, the TKSU also explained:
As a government policy document, the DWP will give coherent instruction to the defence establishment, in particular the military, about government expectations for their roles. It will also provide the rationale and authority for the allocation of resources to the defence forces, and legitimise the spending of public funds for that purpose.
Should the defence establishment wish to make a case for the nation’s gross domestic product to be pegged at a fixed rate for its annual budget, the DWP will have to make the case persuasively. If presented with due diligence, the DWP will build a constituency of advocates within the community of lawmakers, non-governmental organisations and other interest groups.
In this sense then, DWP will act as a tool for the justification of budgetary resources over a multi-year time-frame. The assurance of predictable funding, if successfully obtained, will enhance and stabilise defence planning processes.
And for those who worry that the DWP will reveal our defence secrets:
The transparency that the DWP creates pertaining to the nation’s defence activities domestically has the potential to extend to our neighbours as well as to the larger region.
The DWP is an efficient instrument for confidence — and security-building in that it will state and confirm the country’s bilateral, regional and multilateral obligations and commitments. Its public and open nature will ensure that Malaysia’s intentions are not misinterpreted.
— Malaysian Defence
If you like this post, buy me an espresso. Paypal Payment
View Comments (37)
Yes. Get the DWP done and stick to it. Its an orderly way to do things rather than each service fighting it out and in ad hoc manner
A defence white paper is important so that the politicians and rakyat could measure
1. What is expected from the Army, Navy, Airforce (and IMO MMEA too)
2. Clear commitment on paper to support and maintain defence capabilities.
3. To clearly show to the rakyat why defence is important. How daily lives would be affected if we let our defence down (not able to go fishing, loss of oil platforms, flight disruptions, general safety, destruction of properties due to conflict, loss of lives etc etc)
4. Plans for the future
BTW some older posts by marhalim on this
https://www.malaysiandefence.com/the-unofficial-malaysian-defence-white-paper/
https://www.malaysiandefence.com/defence-policy-or-white-paper/
Some samples of defence white paper
Australia
http://www.defence.gov.au/whitepaper/Docs/2016-Defence-White-Paper.pdf
Philippines
https://www.malaysiandefence.com/australia-signs-deal-for-12-submarines/#comment-353967
Indonesia
https://www.malaysiandefence.com/australia-signs-deal-for-12-submarines/#comment-354900
Just my rambling on future plans for army, navy, airforce and MMEA
https://www.malaysiandefence.com/australia-signs-deal-for-12-submarines/#comment-352218
Hope the information above could help to shape a good comprehensive defence white paper for the security of our country Malaysia.
A good DWP must also have KPIs with time measurements, not just an open ended document. There should be a time limit, say 2019-2034 (15 years) for all the items in the DWP to be fulfilled. For example the Australian DWP is formulated as a plan up till 2035.
China Military Strategy white paper 2015
http://eng.mod.gov.cn/Press/2015-05/26/content_4586805.htm
"Its public and open nature will ensure that Malaysia’s intentions are not misinterpreted."
I don't worry about Malaysia's intentions towards our neighbours via DWP. I worry about the others intentions towards Malaysia and the DWP will give them an advantage in their own 'defense' planning. I am not totally against it if they can limit the amount of info revealed (no mention of any specific hardware or systems, just the budget allocated for what purpose is sufficient to the public in terms of expenses and vague enough to keep outsiders guessing). At the very least it will deter such nonsense like a revision on top of a revised budget done less than 1 year ago.
Think to the WP and decisively, do not dither. Malaysia’s prestige and credibility depends on it.
It would be easier if they just admit that they don't have the expertise to make DWP in the first place. Please step down honorably, and let others do this seriously for our National defence sake.
Reply
Who does actually?
@t(-_- t) ²²
i will nominate you as minister of defence, you seem to know what you're talking about.
@ t(-_- t) ²²
Let others do? Who do you suggest? Do you want to do it?
@ joe
It is better for others to know of our intentions rather than we ourselves does not know the importance of our defence and the consequences of a poorly thought out one!
Further readings
https://www.dia.mil/Portals/27/Documents/News/Military%20Power%20Publications/China_Military_Power_FINAL_5MB_20190103.pdf